The meeting notes are from the themes review team discussion on November 08, 2022. The themes team meets second and fourth Tuesday of every month at 15:00 UTC.
- Where: #themereview channel in make WordPress slack. You can read the full transcript here.
- Agenda: Meeting agenda here.
- Meeting Facilitator: @kafleg
- Note Taker: @kafleg
- Next Meeting: November 23, 2022 in #themereview channel
- Attendees: @shivashankerbhatta, @bijayyadav, @latracal, @alberuni-azad
1. Weekly updates
The themes team published weekly updates about tickets and HelpScout emails. Here is the theme statistic for the past 7 days. More information can be found here.
In the past 7 days,
- 433 tickets were opened
- 427 tickets were closed
- 421 tickets were made live.
- 29 new Themes were made live.
- 392 Theme updates were made live.
- 3 more was approved but is waiting to be made live.
- 6 tickets were not-approved.
- 0 tickets were closed-newer-version-uploaded.
- 421 tickets were made live.
Note: These stats include both the new theme tickets and updated theme tickets as well.
Number of reviewers: 3 (@kafleg, @acosmin, @stalukder03)
Block Theme Stats
- 5 Block themes are live for the past 7 days
- 5 Block themes are currently reviewing
- We have 172 Block Themes in the themes repository.
2. Theme Handbook Update
- Removed commercial link from theme hierarchy page. Thank you @bph for creating the issue.
- Updated FAQs page. Thank you @utz119 and @poena for your help.
Currently, there are 5 open issues in the themes label. You can help with this as well. Thank you, @nielslange and @poena, for going over the handbook.
3. Open Floor
@shivashankerbhatta talked about rules for the designing FSE(block theme) theme. He asked, “Could any of the theme authors redesign the FSE version of their older theme?”
His concern was, block themes are more in the design. So, how we can compare the design of the themes that are submitted to the repository? He said, “We should think more seriously about the FSE themes. Some people did and will do similar designs with different codes and we just left it by mentioning the original author’s credits. Basically, we had not much talked about the appearance.”
Also, he asked, “Do you have any idea to build/introduce the option to switch between classic and FSE? Is there any rule to stop this kind of option?”
@kafleg request him to develop the theme based on it and wants to see how it is implemented.