Here’s the last round of menus usability tests with 23450.6.diff applied.
User #15
Here’s the video.
Step 1: Log in
No issues.
Step 2: Go to menus
No issues.
Step 3: Reorganize pages
No issues.
Step 4: Preview changes
No issues.
Step 5: Remove menu item
No issues.
Step 6: Add another menu
No issues.
Step 7: Add links
No issues.
Step 8: Delete menu
No issues.
User #16
Here’s the video.
Step 1: Log in
No issues.
Step 2: Go to menus
No issues.
Step 3: Reorganize pages
No issues.
Step 4: Preview changes
No issues.
Step 5: Remove menu item
4:35 – When she expanded the menu item, the remove link was below the fold, so she did not see it. This caused confusion.
Step 6: Add another menu
No issues.
Step 7: Add links
No issues.
Step 8: Delete menu
No issues.
Observations/Thoughts
Overall, everything worked great. We added a task to delete a menu in there, to double check that users were able to spot it at the bottom, and they both seemed to find the link easily enough.
The second user found a bug. The extra description items (CSSCSS CSS is an acronym for cascading style sheets. This is what controls the design or look and feel of a site., XFN, Description) were unchecked in screen options, and should not have been showing in the menu item edit screen. Since they were there, the “remove” link was pushed below the fold, which caused her confusion. We’ll need to fix this.